Assessment you can compare

A defensible funding decision starts with a consistent assessment method. In OmniStar, a review type sets the form, the reviewers' roles, the due date and the rules for every review of its kind, so every assessor works the same way.

Reviews gather assessment and do not decide anything: decisions are made separately, through approvals. Every answer a reviewer gives is captured as data, ready for dashboards, reports and the people who decide.

Every score can be compared, ranked and explained, from the first assessment to the final funding recommendation.

You can read more about assessment criteria, merit-based assessment and scoring rubrics in our grants management glossary.

Review  ›  Assessment Panel Review
To continue reviewing this application, please read and agree to the non-disclosure agreement below.
Non-disclosure agreement

As a reviewer you will have access to confidential information about applicants, their organisations and their proposed projects. You agree to use this information only for the purpose of assessing this application, not to disclose it to any other person, and to securely delete any downloaded documents once the review is complete.

You also agree to declare any actual, potential or perceived conflict of interest before reviewing, and to update your declaration if your circumstances change during the assessment period.

✓ I agree ✕ I do not agree
Declare conflict of interest ✓Fill in review form ✓Submit ✓

Please complete the conflict of interest form below.

Application2027/CG-0518 – Urban Cooling Canopy Trial
Primary contactJames Holloway
OrganisationNorthgate City Council
Do you have a conflict of interest? *
▾YesNo
Reason *
✓ Declare and review now ✕ Cancel
Review later? Click here to declare and download review documents.
Declare conflict of interest ✓Fill in review form ✓Submit ✓
Assessment
1. Alignment with program objectivesWeight 40%
12345
2. Capability and track recordWeight 30%
12345
3. Value for moneyWeight 30%
12345
Submit review
›
Review detailsDocumentsApplication versions
Application form – CG-0518.pdf ▾↧ Download all
☰1 / 1272%
Application summary
ProjectUrban Cooling Canopy Trial
OrganisationNorthgate City Council
Amount requested$86,500
Duration24 months
Project objectives
Team and track record
Budget
Trees and planting$52,000
Sensors and monitoring$21,500
Community engagement$13,000
✓Review submitted · panel chair notified
✓NDA and conflicts firstNo review until both are declared
✓Weighted scoringEvery criterion scored consistently
✓Application side by sideRead the documents while you score

How assessment works

Review types

Reusable templates that set the review form with its rated and weighted criteria, the program, the default review period, whether rescoring is allowed and which documents attach automatically.

Suggested reviewers

A ranked list of reviewers, with a plain-language reason for each, drawing on nominations, past reviews, quality, timeliness and upcoming workload.

Bulk review

One reviewer scores and comments on many applications on a single form, comparing similar applications side by side.

Collaborative review

Reviewers comment question by question, mark what needs a response and record a recommendation, then an overall outcome is set.

Locked, then rescored

A submitted review locks. Where the review type allows it, you reopen it for rescoring after a panel discussion, and the original scores are kept.

Review reports

Detail reports show each reviewer's scores and comments per criterion, and overview reports compare applications by aggregate score.

The right reviewers

Applicants can nominate reviewers on their form, and staff can add their own. Suggested reviewers ranks the candidates and shows each person's reviews due over the next four weeks, so you spread the load before you assign.

  • Nominated reviewers on each application
  • Areas of expertise on contact records, which can be synced from ORCID
  • Reviewers update their own availability
  • Review history and workload on each person's record

More than applications

The same review process works wherever your programs need expert input.

Applications

Expert and panel review of applications, tied to the exact version that was assessed.

Milestone reports

Progress and final reports reviewed by staff or external specialists.

Documents and variations

Related documents and variation forms reviewed before a decision.

General forms

Collaborative review extended to general forms.

Reviewer roles

Roles such as lead or secondary reviewer can change what the form asks each person.

Automatic creation

Workflows can create reviews and act on their results, for example once an application is eligible.

A process that stands up

Before reviewers see an application, they accept a non-disclosure statement and declare any conflict of interest. A significant conflict cancels the review automatically. Submitted reviews lock, rescoring keeps the original, and every change is recorded.

  • Conflict of interest declarations before access
  • Applications and attachments read in in-system document viewers, limiting downloads of sensitive material
  • Reviews deactivated and reactivated with their own permissions
  • Original scores kept through rescoring
  • Support for merit-based processes under the Commonwealth Grants Rules and Principles (CGRPs)

Up to 60% less administration time

Cancer Council Victoria, after combining its three systems into one with OmniStar.

Floating Image

Case study

Cancer Council Victoria

We care about funding world-class cancer research. We don't want our applicants spending all their time on administrative processes when they could be focusing on the research that saves lives.

Renee Clapham PhD Manager, Research Governance, Cancer Council Victoria
Victoria Cancercouncil New Logo 82F4b2

Frequently asked questions

Merit-based assessment compares applications against published assessment criteria, so funding goes to the applications that best meet the program's objectives. In OmniStar Grants, every assessor completes the same review form for the review type.

Yes. Each review type has its own form and settings, and you create as many review types as your programs need.

Yes. Review forms support weighted scoring, so the criteria that matter most in your guidelines carry the most influence in the final score.

Submitted reviews are locked. Where the review type allows rescoring, an administrator reopens the review with the original answers in place, and OmniStar keeps the original assessment and a full history of scores.

Review reports and dashboards show scores by criterion, reviewer and application. Decision Scenarios then model which applications the available funding can support. See ranking and funding scenarios.

Suggested reviewers ranks candidates on whether they were nominated, their experience with the review type, round and program, the quality and timeliness of past reviews, and their upcoming workload, and explains each suggestion.

Related features and use cases

Reviewer portal and collaborative review

Give external reviewers and panel members a secure portal, or a one-click link, to complete individual, bulk and collaborative reviews, without email attachments or spreadsheets.

Conflict of interest management

Ask for a conflict of interest declaration and a non-disclosure statement before every review, act on conflicts automatically, and keep every declaration and override on the record.

Ranking and funding scenarios

Compare applications on their reviews, then test which ones your budget can fund with Decision Scenarios, before the outcomes are approved and applied to every application at once.

Competitive grant rounds

Run multi-stage, merit-based grant rounds in one system, from online applications and eligibility checks to scoring, ranking and award notifications.

Scholarships, fellowships and awards

Manage scholarships, fellowships and awards from online application to panel selection, offer, agreement and progress reporting, in one configurable system.

Trusted by industry leading organisations

NHMRC Logo UWA Logo The University of Queensland Logo Siemens Logo Sunway University Logo SVHM Logo Department Of Health Logo National Breast Cancer Foundation Logo SA Health Logo RHC Logo

Ready to book a demo?

Book with us today and unlock the power of OmniStar.

Floating Image